Posts Tagged ‘refugees’



In the past we have had superheroes who flew, who possessed amazing strength, astounding agility, could stretch and duplicate.  Superman, Spiderman, Batman & Captain America were the heroes we read about in comic books, fantasy universes superimposed over our own real world.

Today though, we need a new hero.  One firmly rooted in reality and our world, because our foe is the politician who lives in a fantasy world, a fantasy world that he is trying to impose upon our own.  And, if successful, will usher in a time of pain and suffering upon the innocents, and will wreck this once great country.

His tool for accomplishing this goal?  The lie.  And, thus is born Truth Matters Person.  Unlike most prior superheroes, Truth Matters Person has no set age or sex or gender identity or race or religion.  Truth Matters Person consists of everyday people who look for and do not turn away from truth, and then are not afraid to tell that truth to all.

All of these stories contain only part of the truth, a necessity in order to achieve brevity.  However, at the end of each there will be links to the more complete truth.  Also, all words spoken by Trump in these stories are actual quotes from his tweets and his speeches.

Episode 1:   The Dangerous Hordes of Refugees

2ff1cd0ecda4a9a2b839be9fb4611b56“Refugees from Syria are now pouring into our great country. Who knows who they are – some could be ISIS. Is our president insane?”  “Refugees from Syria over 10k plus more coming. Lots young males, poorly vetted.”

No Donald.  The truth of the matter is that we do not take in many refugees at all asian_girl_vol__1_by_animegamer001compared to other countries.  Canada has taken in 32,400 for example.  And this is out of 4.9 million Syrian refugees.

Of those that the United States has taken in, 72% are either women or children under the age of 14.

22868475614_e0f545173a_bBut, but, but the vetting, there is no vetting.   “Altogether, under the Clinton plan, you’d be admitting hundreds of thousands of refugees from the Middle East with no system to vet them…”

I’m glad you brought that up Donald.  The truth of the matter is that we have an extremely asian_girl_vol__1_by_animegamer001thorough vetting system for refugees, more thorough than any other in the world.   It takes on average 18 to 24 months for a refugee to go through this process.

It starts with the United Nations High Commission for Refugees interviewing and checking refugees and deciding which ones should be forwarded to the US as a potential refugee for the United States.  From there, the refugee has to pass numerous interviews from several agencies, their biometric data collected and checked against several security and law enforcement data bases, more interviews, and more checks.  During this process the FBI, the Department of Homeland Security, the Defense Department,  U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services,  Department of State, and the National Counterterrorism Center check their identity and backgrounds against several databases.

The link provided below by Natasha Hall, whose job was to vet these refugees, is an interesting read and highly recommended.  Often those countries that many are claiming do not have enough documentation –  such as Iraq and Syria –  do have more than enough to properly check people out.  And, if there is not enough documentation on a particular candidate, then that person does not get through.

Further, there are medical evaluations done, and towards the end of the process, the refugees have to attend a Cultural Orientation to teach them about practices and customs here in the United States.  By the way, once in, they are not just let loose.  Instead, various different agencies whose purpose is to help the refugee settle in and find jobs meet them and guide them during this initial period.


c07c45_61a2c43deb564d6fa3857650cbe3858f.jpg_srz_1903_1269_85_22_0.50_1.20_0.00_jpg_srzWe “are letting tens of thousands of people come in from Syria and nobody knows who these people are and a lot of those people are ISIS.” “We have no idea who we are letting in. You’ve seen what happened.”


Donald, a lie does not become truth just because it is repeated.  I have already shown you that we do know who we are letting into our country.  And, the truth is, that we have seenasian_girl_vol__1_by_animegamer001 what has happened by letting these Syrian refugees in.   We save lives, and give people who are suffering and afraid and lost a chance to create a new home.

And despite the claims that these refugees are a burden on our economy, they have proven to be a benefit.  As the PBS article linked to at the bottom notes, they add to the labor market and add needed skills.  As the US News article notes, also linked to at the bottom, while Cleveland spent $4.8 million dollars settling refugees into their area, they wound up creating an economic benefit of $48 million dollars through increased demand for goods and services and because refugees start up new businesses that hire people.

As for the danger they pose, so far there have been no fatal attacks by any Syrian refugee in the United States.  As the Atlantic article notes, also linked to at the bottom,  over the last 40 years the United States has accepted 3.25 million refugees.  Only 20 of them have been convicted of attempting or committing terrorist acts in the United States.  Further, only three Americans have been killed in attacks by refugees, and these were by Cuban refugees during the 1970’s.

Due to our already extreme vetting system, refugees  pose no more danger to you and to the citizens of the US than any other citizen.  In fact, most of the attacks carried out by Muslims in the United States have been by permanent residents or native born citizens who had become radicalized.

The truth is, instead of being afraid of the refugees, we should be welcoming them.  Instead of turning the United States into a Fortress of Solitude and Isolation, we should live up to our reputation of welcoming the weary and embrace our common humanity.  We should be showing the world that we have the courage and decency to act upon our empathy for those in need instead of allowing overwrought fear to cause us to spread hatred and rejection.

Ka pow

And the Truth Shall Keep Us Free!

To learn more both for personal satisfaction and in order to better spread the truth, check out these links.

On the demographics of the Syrian refugees,

From Migration Policy


From the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees



Good article about Syrian refugees by US News


More information about our refugee vetting system.

Here is the article by Natasha Hall, the former immigration official whose job was to vet refugees.


From the US Department of State, the graphic at the bottom of the article provides a very good guide to the process.


The New York Times provides a simpler version of the same graphic I mentioned above about the vetting process.


And here is an article by a refugee who went through the process.


On the dangers of refugees. 

Here is an Atlantic article about the “dangers’ of refugees.


And one from CNN on the same subject.


On the economic impact of refugees,

An article from US News


And from PBS



Read Full Post »

There is a conservative meme going around about Syrian refugees that claims that almost all of them are men and that they are cowards. It is wrong on both counts.


First off, if these conservatives would quit relying on photos of doubtful origin and whose circumstances are unknown and instead spend a few minutes doing the research they would discover that according to the UN Refugee Agency that about half the refugees are women. Also, about half the refugees are also under the age of 17.

Now, where the conservatives are partly right in regards to a predominance of male refugees is in regards to those attempting to cross the Mediterranean by boat in order to get to Europe. Those refugees are about 70% male. However, this includes all refugees whether from Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria or Africa. And even here, there is a good reason why they might be mostly male refugees – such crossings are extremely dangerous. I would think that the picture of the drowned three year old Syrian boy whose body washed ashore earlier this year should be plenty of evidence for why it is mostly men who cross the water in leaking and unseaworthy boats, with the idea of bringing their families over in a safer way once they have established a beginning.

That is not cowardly.

But this only deals with part of the reason why conservatives call these Syrian males cowards. An argument made by the ignorant is that these men should be staying and fighting for their homes and lands and that the fact that they are not shows that they are indeed cowards. To be quite frank – that argument is pure bullshit, and ignores both the reality on the ground in Syria, on human nature, and on the nature of war and violence.

What sparked this blog is an article in the October 26, 2015 issue of the New Yorker. Their reporter at large piece by Nicholas Shmidle, titled “Ten Borders”. It is a story about one refugee, Ghaith, a law student who escaped from Syria and into Sweden. And, appropriately enough, it is about a male who left his wife behind. It nicely tells why this meme is so very, very wrong.

To start, I rather like this quote in regards to illustrating part of the reasons why Ghaith did not stay and fight, and it perfectly illustrates the simplistic nature of the conservative meme and their naïve and simplistic ideas about revolutions and wars.

Ghaith saw the war as “a battle between two losing sides”. He told me, “Each side thinks that you’re either with them or against them. My family was not with any side. We just wanted to get by

The two big sides in Syria are, of course, Assad and ISIS – a brutal dictator and an even more brutal Islamic terrorist group. Neither are likely to inspire trust and loyalty. In addition there are the Free Syrian Army, Jaish al-Fatah, Islamic Front and many others. How do you choose a side when all are bad and all are fighting each other?

Further, most people are not military. Ghaith was a law student studying criminal law. He is a small man, just over five feet. Once conscripted he would become a good candidate for a dead man. Or, even worse in his words, become a”killer” instead of a “victim”.

What made it even more complicated is that he is an Alawite, a religious minority group who some rebel groups target and assassinate. Why? Because Assad’s family are also Alawites. You might think that he would thereby receive some sort of protection or favoritism from Assad’s regime because of that link. However, his family has not been a fan of Assad. One of Ghaith’s nieces posted a comment on Facebook that “condemned a barrel bomb attack by the Syrian Air Force on civilians in Homs. Government agents snatched two of Ghaith’s friends off the streets and took them away”.

A lone man fighting many different well armed mutually antagonistic groups is not going to live long. To believe otherwise is to believe in a delusion.

Ghaith initially resisted fleeing Syria due to concerns about his mother and his wife. However, as the pressure mounted for him to join the military both his wife and his mother strongly urged him to flee as he was the one greatest at risk. The idea was that if he could get out and settle someplace he could send for them.

“She’s coming, too” he said after reaching Sweden, though he acknowledged that it would take time. Sweden provides a family reunification program but only for asylum seekers with residency status.

I had already mentioned that Ghaith managed to reach Sweden. Looking at this deceitful meme you would think such journeys are easy to do. However, it took Ghaith several tries, tries which often ended in failure and difficulties.
At the international terminal in Beirut his forged passport failed to pass inspection. As a result:

He and about fifty other foreigners shared a dark cell, sleeping on the floor. They had to defecate in buckets…. Naim Houry, a Human Rights Watch researcher, said that some refugees had been kept there for “weeks, months, and even years” while awaiting deportation. One day, Ghaith watched, horrified, as a pregnant prisoner fell to the floor, blood pooling around her.

A friend who had also been caught and detained had teeth jerked out with pliers and his back was covered in cigarette burns. Another friend died while in detention.

I won’t go into the details of Ghaith’s efforts, but each step provided its own challenge and dangers. Smugglers are expensive and often untrustworthy. Refugees are subject to beatings and rape. And, of course, dying. “The smugglers behaved like jail wardens, Bahaa added, “throwing us around left and right””.

One trip by boat was cancelled due to the Turkish Cost guard seizing the first two boats that had set out.

Another boat did set out. But it was overloaded and small, and the seas rough and turned back. When it reached shore the captain jumped and ran while the craft sped into the shallow water and its “propellers jamming on rocks”.

Escape is not safe. That seems to be something the promulgators of the above meme and others like it ignore. Is it cowardly to leave your family in a place that is relatively safer while you go to find and create a better place?  I don’t think so.

What also struck me is that despite the dangers as well as the rejection and anger the refugees encountered they also encountered many people along the way who provided food and shelter, directions and helpful advice to the refugees – Turks, Greeks, Hungarians. People recognizing fellow humans in desperate need.

As for now, Ghaith is intent on becoming Swedish. Other than friends from Syria who had also made it out, Ghaith “cared little for Syria anymore. Once his wife arrived, they would have children and he would raise them as Swedes. He didn’t care if his kids spoke Arabic. He added in broken English, “I worship Sweden.””

In short, the Syrian refugees are not predominantly male. They are not cowards. They are human beings fleeing an impossible situation with the same hopes, desires, and dreams as ourselves. The human dream.

Around the same time, Austrian authorities found an abandoned poultry truck with seventy-one dead refugees inside. Ghaith said that he couldn’t help but feel lucky: “I made it, while thousands of others didn’t. Some died on the way, some died in Syria. Every day, you hear about people drowning. Just think about how much every Syrian is suffering inside Syria to endure the suffering of this trip.” He paused. “In Greece, someone asked me, ‘Why take the chance?’ I said ‘In Syria, there’s a hundred-per-cent chance you’re going to die. If the chance of making it to Europe is even one percent, then that means there is a one-percent chance of your leading an actual life.’”

Read Full Post »